Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

I found this whole Lenovo Adware-gate very hypocritical. Why everyone blames the messenger Lenovo but not the source Superfish? Why? Is it because Lenovo is a Chinese company whereas Superfish is a Iserali-American company based in Silicon Valley?

Before this adware-gate, EVERY PC manufacturer bundles adware, HP, Dell, Acer, Lenovo, Asus to name a few top players(Apple perhaps is the only exception as I don't count them as a PC manufacturer). Did anyone bother to look if there were tons of similar security risks with those?



Because there are all sorts of insecure malware/adware out there. They're all various levels of evil and a known quantity of badness.

Lenovo is a company that you paid your money to to buy a laptop. It shouldn't come pre-infected with something that compromises your security and privacy.


Lenovo had a chance to redeem itself by apologizing, removing the software and quickly distancing itself from the company.

They screwed up by denying there was problem in the first place. Which means they were defending both their decision to install Superfish as well as, by proxy, Superfish itself.

Thus they are seen to be either incompetent (can't trust them) or malicious (also can't trust them).

Also consumers never bought Superfish. They paid for a relatively expensive piece of hardware from Lenovo and got screwed. They are right to blame Lenovo for it.



Why everyone blames the messenger Lenovo but not the source Superfish?

Because Lenova is the one who took your hundreds to thousand+ dollars and in return compromised your experience (for what has to be pennies). And in this case it caused a serious security compromise?

"EVERY PC manufacturer bundles adware"

Crapware/bloatware and adware are very different things. Dell installs some bloatware crap that I can uninstall (and even that is, truly, unacceptable. Again, they can't make more than a dollar or two on that junk, yet they compromise the user experience), but they don't MITM my secure communications, or compromise my security.

This has nothing to do with Lenova being a Chinese company. Further, no one expects anything out of Superfish (some slimy adware company), but they do expect standards from Lenova.


BTW, it's Lenovo. I wouldn't be surprised if other manufacturers had adware installed but perhaps remedied quickly rather than a PR disaster.




Consider applying for YC's Fall 2025 batch! Applications are open till Aug 4

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: