Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Going off on a tangent, but what's the point of washing an orange?


Assuming you wash your other produce (you probably should, especially if you buy organic and don't like e. coli.), the question you're asking is just "how does the crap on the outside get into the inside?" The usual route for those contaminants is peel -> hands -> fleshy fruity bits. A lot more is transferred than you might think.

For a bit of fun, try the same idea with a few dirty potatoes. Wash two thoroughly, and leave one unwashed. Peel a washed one, peel the unwashed one, and peel the last washed one. You'll observe that both of the latter two are much dirtier than the first one [0]. It won't be as dirty as what you started with, but it'll still be enough to cause some minor taste issues and (depending on the type of soil) make the dish feel gritty as you eat it. Contaminants you can't physically see/taste/feel are transferred the same way.

[0] There's a minor confounder in that potato flesh can oxidize, and that discoloration might be perceived as dirt. It's not as bad as with, e.g., apples though. Just work quickly, and the difference in dirt levels should be apparent.


Once I saw how fruit is transported and stocked, I wash all of it regardless of whether I am going to eat the skin or not.


Its the same type of idiotic comment under any tiktok/short/fb video from any kitchen when chefs work without gloves: „EeW, UsE glOveS!!11“ That tiny amount of dirt wont kill you, but definitely keep your immune system in working order


The issue is not the literal dirt. Dirt is fine. The issues are the pesticides and industrial contamination like whatever's on the floor of the packing plant or grocery store.


Plenty of ways to keep my immune system updated providing myself scratches and cuts while mountain biking / trail running, let alone eating snacks while on the trail with my hands absolutely not clean, or by simply breathing in a forest.

But ingesting the black residue from exposure to diesel smoke while in transport is not for me, thanks. Feel free to train your immune system to dispatch tar.


Has anyone else seen oranges encrusted with this black residue from diesel smoke? It's not an issue in my country.


Have I written encrusted oranges?


There can still be bacteria or viruses on the produce, generally for people with weak health it is recommended to wash all the produce they consume.

There are also many *-icides, but they are generally quite hydrophobic so it's not easy to wash them off.

But you are right about the dirt, there is even some evidence suggesting ingesting some dirt may be good for your gut health.


Maybe in order not to get the (particularly bad, as far as I know) pesticides on your hands? I wash my hands after having peeled an orange, but washing the orange itself seems like a waste to me.

I don't really know. I could understand if it was for zesting, but then you're supposed to use untreated oranges anyway because the pesticides don't wash out easily because of the oils on the orange's skin.


She is 1.9 years old and anything that looks like food will be bitten. But to tell the truth, you even need to wash bananas: pesticide residues (you can transfer chemicals to your hands and then to the editable part), can collect dirt/bacteria/rodent excrement.


The skin might be dirty, so cutting a knife through it will slightly contaminate the insides


And thats a good thing? It wont kill you, but your immune system will be busy and trained.


Wikipedia mentions that immunity to any particular strain of norovirus lasts for 6 to 24 months.


I’ve read online that the skin of fruits can contain bugs and larvae that when washed help keep your fruit longer and prevent things like fruit flies.


It depends on a lot of things. You could just as easily wash off the wax that was applied to the orange and make it spoil faster that way, and the extra moisture will cause delicate fruits (like berries) to spoil more quickly than any gains you'll get from the removal of dirt and larvae if you don't dry them very thoroughly.


i came here to leave the same comment, and I checked beforehand if someone noticed the same.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: