Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

[flagged]



Have you considered seeing a psychologist? Not being able to control your effusions is the sign of a significant problem.


[dead]


Coffee effects around 30% of people with a strong laxative effect.

https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/2338272/


And yet 30% of people aren't shitting in the street.


I hope it's a lot more than 30% of people not shitting in the street.


Good lord based on this guy I am now worried…


Your opinions have been voted down so many times this thread is filled with your dead comments and not a single person has vouched for you other than me. I can no longer vouch for you.

Also youre flame baiting which is a clear violation of HN policy. @dang

You probably need to take a class on improving your poor reasoning skills and as another poster said: seek mental health care.


I don’t think saying you need to talk to a doctor is flamebaiting…


In the manner you have been doing it... yes.

It doesnt matter what we think only what the mods think friend.


I don’t think they care…


Yeah because they have public restrooms available.


No, because they can still manage their bowel movements.


weird that youre not getting the meaning of: "Strong laxative effect"


I am, you aren’t. If it meant what you suggest, coffee wouldn’t be served.


It probably shouldn't be in places where there's no public restroom access.

It's probably still a holdover from when San Francisco wasn't as crowded and had adequate access to public restrooms.

It's not really an issue in most of the country because there's at least adequate public restroom access.


No, coffee doesn’t cause people to involuntarily shit, that’s not what a strong laxative is or does.


You're sort of a broken record at this point.

You just say whatever you think with no supporting evidence.

Viewing ones unsupported opinions as more accurate than science (especially in a medical context) is considered delusional thinking by the psychiatric community and it's definitely indicative for a referral to a psychiatrist.


[flagged]


.Your opinions have been voted down so many times this thread is filled with your dead comments and not a single person has vouched for you other than me. I can no longer vouch for you.

Also youre flame baiting which is a clear violation of HN policy. @dang

You probably need to take a class on improving your poor reasoning skills and as another poster said: seek mental health care.


Not that it matters, but I gained ~60 votes from repeatedly telling you to seek medical advice for your uncontrollable bowels.


Anybody can say anything on the internet...

Because of all your flagged dead posts. It's literally impossible to navigate this thread.

Takes more than one person to flag a post to a dead status also.

Best of luck to you!


You and OP appear to agree there is a significant problem, you just disagree where the "blame" lies.

OP suggests the built environment is insufficient. You baselessly assume OP must have a serious medical issue as, apparently, you can't imagine that the built environment is really the appropriate villain to finger in this case.

Before anyone jumps up to accuse me of nefarious intent and of being secretly on the side of "America's built environment could stand to be improved" I'll just openly admit that's exactly where I stand and save you a bit of furious typing.


[flagged]


over half the world shits in the streets because of inadequate public restroom access.

You're clearly not educated on this.

https://www.google.com/amp/s/www.bbc.com/news/world-asia-ind...


And India has launched campaigns to stop that behaviour including ads telling women not to marry a man who doesn't have a toilet in his house

If you watch videos on street shifting in India it's clearly not just a necessity or poverty, it's something they actively seek out and prefer

Emergencies are Emergencies, like explosive vomiting or something, but as a rule it should be an extreme exception.


[flagged]


[flagged]


We've banned this account for egregiously breaking the site guidelines. Please don't create accounts to break HN's rules with.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html


Nope, you said you shat yourself in the streets of SF and I told you to seek medical attention, and you could not handle it. That’s it.


I see. You have no idea what's going on right now.

You might even be posting from inside a mental institution for all I know.

Well good luck to you.

Hope you get the mental health care you need.


[flagged]


[flagged]


? Did you double post this?


[flagged]


What makes you think I’m not also terminally online? Heh


one instance of shitting in the street is hardly a sign of a “significant problem” calm down hoss


[flagged]


“shit happens” as they say


Thanks Doctor.


Telling someone to see a doctor isn’t medical advice. Telling someone not to shit in the street is also not medical advice; it’s basic human decency.


your opinions in this thread have been flagged so many times I can't vouch for them anymore.

you really need to take a class to improve your poor reasoning skills.


None of this changes the basic fact that you need medical attention if you are shitting uncontrollably in the street.


Your opinions have been voted down so many times this thread is filled with your dead comments and not a single person has vouched for you other than me. I can no longer vouch for you. Also youre flame baiting which is a clear violation of HN policy. @dang

You probably need to take a class on improving your poor reasoning skills and as another poster said: seek mental health care.


Like I said before, none of this matters to the core point; regardless of SFs lack of public restrooms, no healthy person is shitting in the street.


@dang


Whether the GP has a medical issue or not, people with bowel-control problems still deserve to be able to travel the city. There just need to be restrooms available for them. There's no simple cure, so their doctor won't be able to solve that problem for them.


I didn’t make any statements about any of that, he said he shat in the street uncontrollably. That’s a medical issue.


Presumably "since I could find a restroom" was a typo, and they meant the reason it happened was that they [couldn't] find a restroom.


Nothing should result in a healthy person being unable to control their bowels to the point of shitting in the streets.


Says your uninformed medical opinion.


Lmao yes, my uninformed medical opinion does say that.


I don't know if being proud of having ignorance regarding healthcare is a good thing.

Does not bode well for your future.

Do you also think doctors are a scam?


I’m not a doctor, but you should see one if you’re shitting in the street.


Your opinions have been voted down so many times this thread is filled with your dead comments and not a single person has vouched for you other than me. I can no longer vouch for you.

Also youre flame baiting which is a clear violation of HN policy. @dang

You probably need to take a class on improving your poor reasoning skills and as another poster said: seek mental health care.


[flagged]


@dang


You defecated on the street because you couldn't control your bowels. You seriously need to see a doctor.


Not sure what you expect to happen here…


I disagree with this. This could’ve been caused by taking a morning coffee and having a long commute.


Exactly. You can get a venti coffee at Starbucks and get a refill for 52 cents and if you're not from San Francisco, you don't realize how brutal the public toilet situation is until its too late.


[sharing too much mode: on]

Coffee almost always makes me "move my bowels" pretty fast. I solve this by making sure I never have coffee unless a restroom is available.

A corollary to this is that long flights are a nightmare to me. I mostly avoid having in-flight meals, if I can.


Not sure about the corollary as long flights always have restrooms and the time to use them. But maybe you are just uncomfortable on airplane toilets which is fine.


Oh, I've used them. It's uncomfortable, plus there's usually a long line both before and after you... Not the best if you're in a hurry.


Literally been to hundreds of cities all over the world and have always been able to find a public restroom until San Francisco!

Although I would imagine New York City might be the same, never been there.


30% of us has this laxative effect.

I think it's a very healthy effect to be honest.

It cleanses our digestive system.


Ugh, that sucks. You have my sincere sympathy!


I just drank a huge amount of Starbucks.


[flagged]


If you have irritable bowel syndrome, it's basically hard to treat, very common, and solved by a simple thing: availability of public restrooms.

It's not a shame to feel the sudden urge to take a shit. What's a shame is blaming people for feeling the urge.

> There is no world in which a healthy person must shit on the street.

Healthy people are not the only ones a city must be designed for. From Wikipedia: "About 10–15% of people in the developed world are believed to be affected by IBS."

And note IBS is not the only reason to feel the sudden urge to take a dump.


[flagged]


Around 30% of people experience a strong laxative effect from coffee.

It's actually really healthy as it keeps your digestive system and colon cleansed.

It's only an issue if there's no public restrooms.

I hope you learned something today.

https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/2338272/

https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/speaking-of-science/wp/2...


[flagged]


If actual an scientific white paper from PubMed with research and data does not convince you that coffee has a strong laxative effect on around 30% of people, then there's not much else to say.

There's still people who believe the world is flat despite all evidence to the contrary.

It's very difficult to have a discussion with someone who prefers their own opinions over science.


[flagged]


Over half the population of the world shits in the street.

It's not a medical symptom.

It's a symptom of poor access to restrooms.

https://www.google.com/amp/s/www.bbc.com/news/world-asia-ind...


[flagged]


Yes its sad that an American city is having the same public restroom access issues as third world countries.


[flagged]


Its sad that so many people have flagged your opinions because they're so bad.

This whole comment chain is just a bunch of dead posts of yours.

I even vouched for you on all of them but numerous people kept flagging them.

You should really look into taking a class on improving reasoning skills.


[flagged]


@dang


And you think pestering someone like this is a winner?


Coffee affects me strongly. What can I say. I get a cleanse every morning for 3 bucks. Cleansing your digestive tract is actually really good for you. People pay big bucks for cleanses.


[flagged]


More often than not: no, the cannot.

Do you believe medicine has the answer for every chronic condition? Doctors are often unable to help you.


[flagged]


> 100% of the time a doctor can help you in some way

Nothing that starts with the claim "100%" is ever true, you can be 100% certain of that.

Seriously though, you speak as if your digestive system has never betrayed you, and therefore you're unfamiliar with these matters.

Trust me: there are some things your doctor cannot help you with, at least, not to the point you can walk in a city without public restrooms. Some things are not even medical conditions -- and IBS is "idiopathic" in many cases, meaning doctors don't have a clue -- and some conditions that you would consider anomalous actually fall within the normal human spectrum.

You'll feel the urge to contradict me: don't. You probably don't know about this, but both me and the other commenter you're arguing with do. Realize that your experience is not everybody else's.


What does any of this have to do with what I said? Regardless of how much a doctor can help you or not, if you’re shitting uncontrollably in the streets, you need to seek medical attention to determine if they can do anything about it.


thanks for your concern! I get a check up every year! healthy as a horse!

Having regular bowel movements is actually a really healthy thing.

It's only really a problem when there's no public restrooms available.


[flagged]


If actual an scientific white paper from PubMed with research and data does not convince you that coffee has a strong laxative effect on around 30% of people, then there's not much else to say. There's still people who believe the world is flat despite all evidence to the contrary.

It's very difficult to have a discussion with someone who prefers their own opinions over science.


Your citation is irrelevant; being unable to control your bowels to the point of shitting in the street is not healthy, and you should seek a doctor.


[flagged]


You feel sorry for my family because you shat in the street and refuse to accept that you drinking Starbucks is not a valid reason to do that?


Your opinions have been voted down so many times this thread is filled with your dead comments and not a single person has vouched for you other than me. I can no longer vouch for you. Also youre flame baiting which is a clear violation of HN policy. @dang

You probably need to take a class on improving your poor reasoning skills and as another poster said: seek mental health care.


Why did you spam this all over the thread?


he thinks whether something is true or not just depends on how much upvotes it gets


Are you a doctor or something? You’re not this posters friend nor in a social position where it’s appropriate to insist on their health status. (Pointing this out because you might simply not know you’re crossing a line.)


[flagged]


Yes, you asked a question, and then insisted further because the answer isn’t good enough for you. You’re not this persons friend, you’re not this persons doctor and you haven’t claimed any medical experience. You’re being a weirdo. Let it go, dude.


[flagged]


Nothing the OP said made it seem like they were fine pooping in the street. If anything it’s pretty clear they don’t think it’s acceptable. They just don’t think it’s a medical issue. You’re insisting that it is, but you’re not their friend and you’re not a doctor and you don’t have medical training in identifying what is normal and abnormal bowel behavior. That’s being a weirdo because you’re crossing a social line here. Even if you personally think it is, you’re not in a social position where your insistence isn’t incredibly rude.

Several people are telling you to chill out/back off not because it’s acceptable to shit on the street, but because it’s not acceptable to insist on the health status of someone without first establishing either rapport or appropriate relevant knowledge that justifies breaking a social boundary. You have no justification, so your suggest was a little nosey, and your insistence is flagrantly rude.


https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37446500

>Coffee affects me strongly. What can I say. I get a cleanse every morning for 3 bucks. Cleansing your digestive tract is actually really good for you. People pay big bucks for cleanses.

sounds like OP

1. knows that he gets uncontrollable diarrhea from coffee.

2. enjoys it. why else do it every morning?


[flagged]


Dude I’m just gonna take my own advice and go play Baldurs Gate lol. Have a nice day


I don't think anyone cares if you are "here" or not.


Bet youre fun at parties....


I don’t shit in the street on my way there.


Your opinions have been voted down so many times this thread is filled with your dead comments and not a single person has vouched for you other than me. I can no longer vouch for you. Also youre flame baiting which is a clear violation of HN policy. @dang

You probably need to take a class on improving your poor reasoning skills and as another poster said: seek mental health care.


…are you alright dude?


having regular bowel movements is actually really healthy.. it's only an issue if youre in a place with no public restrooms available


This isn't a regular bowel movement.


Regular as in "occuring at uniform intervals"


If your regular bowel movement involves shitting in the street, you need immediate mental health intervention.


Your opinions have been voted down so many times this thread is filled with your dead comments and not a single person has vouched for you other than me. I can no longer vouch for you. Also youre flame baiting which is a clear violation of HN policy @dang.

You probably need to take a class on improving your poor reasoning skills and as another poster said: seek mental health care.


[flagged]


We've banned this account for egregiously breaking the site guidelines. Please don't create accounts to break HN's rules with.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html


Eh, you got the other guy so this was worth. See you in a few months.

Worth considering why I'm consistently able to gather top 5% of points per day though, if I'm so objectionable.


That's easy: points are mostly a function of time spent on the site.

What's objectionable is not determined by points.

https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=false&so...


@dang


There aren’t actually tags on HN, just fyi, but if there were it’d be a backtick.




Consider applying for YC's Fall 2025 batch! Applications are open till Aug 4

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: