Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Wars that were taking place under the Articles, the later two of which started during the time of the Articles:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cherokee%E2%80%93American_wars

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Northwest_Indian_War

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shays'_Rebellion - Note that this last one was a Civil War.

The US is currently in 24th place on the corruptions index: https://www.transparency.org/en/cpi/2022/index/usa

And it seems that corruption was not unknown in the states during the Confederacy period, and is claimed to have increased during the Confederacy: https://www2.byui.edu/i-learn/examples/AF_beforetext.pdf

> Between 1776 and 1787 corruption in state governments increased. States where debtors gained control of the legislatures issued large quantities of paper money which depreciated rapidly in value. In Rhode Island the small farmers in the assembly adopted a Force Act requiring creditors to accept the money at original value. Creditors in other states were also discriminated against by mortgage stay laws which prevented mortgage foreclosures for indefinite periods. The problem of factions within a republic, that was supposed to be solved by keeping republics small like the states, seemed became acute as legislatures became controlled by one faction or another and those factions passed discriminatory legislation.

> There were many disputes and tensions between the states that arose over foreign and interstate commerce. The states began using their power to levy tariffs after the war when England dumped such quantities of cheap goods in America that domestic producers were threatened with ruin. As the tariffs were not uniform among the states, commerce gravitated toward such low-tariff states as Rhode Island. Other states, jealous of this trade, began levying retaliatory tariffs against the goods of those favored states. Merchants and manufacturers wanted an end to destructive interstate tariffs and commercial rivalry, as well as aid in their dealing with foreign governments. States also began to argue with each other over the control of rivers and ports so essential to foreign and interstate trade; causing more bitter disputes between the states.

I got the bookends, you can address "global economic whipsaw manipulation, climate crisis, mass incarceration, widespread poverty" if you want.



A farmers’ tax protest in Worcester was not exactly what I meant by “endless war” but I certainly appreciate how good you are at copying, and then pasting.


Over 2000 dead in the Northwest Indian War.

I normally wouldn't have copy and pasted that much text, but I thought I'd save anyone the time of having to scroll through a 63 page PDF.


Ok, so 4000 dead soldiers makes a one-year war "endless." I understand completely.


No, the fact that conflicts never ceased under the articles makes the war "endless". By the way, it was a 10 year war, not a 1 year war.

And would it have been preferable if any colony could, itself, decide to start a confrontation? "in 1786 the Kentucky militia launched the first major frontier military action since the end of the Revolutionary War."


Holy cow, are you still copying and pasting stuff into this thread?

To save you the effort: I am familiar with US history.


> are you still copying and pasting stuff into this thread?

You bet. And I will keep on keeping on into the future. Though I've probably reached my limit for this back-and-forth.

Calling a 10 year war a 1 year war is "familiar with US history"?

Let's go to another confederated country as an example of what might have happened had the US stayed under the Articles of Confederation.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_wars_involving_Switzer...

It looks like, after the founding and expansion of Switzerland, they had to deal with a number of civil wars (at least one involving no conflict, though others had deaths), as well as periodic wars with surrounding great powers.


Lovely.


Just be happy he's not one of those types that cites links that don't back up his claims as a debate tactic.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: