Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

The simple reform is to not have EU handle vaccine procurement anymore.



Valid opinion, but I disagree.


Fair disagreement!


I'm sure that would work out fine for the wealthy EU countries. Though the small countries might not have the same leverage.

But in the long run, wouldn't it be bad for all of us, if it takes eastern European countries a lot longer to reopen?


This whole topic is about how the EU screwed up the whole thing.

It would be hard for individual countries to do any worse.

Tiny Israel did vastly better that the EU, so the size of the EU clearly didn't help.


> It would be hard for individual countries to do any worse.

It would be pretty easy for any individual countries that don't actually produce vaccines to do worse.

Just look at Canada, for instance. It's a rich country that hoarded vaccine pre-orders (Enough to vaccinate its population three times over), and what was the result? A lower vaccination rate than the EU. That's because Canada does not control any part of the R&D or manufacturing process, so its orders got pushed to the back of the line. And neither do most of the countries in the EU.

What makes you think Slovakia or Greece, or Italy are going to be any better off? What makes you think that if vaccine procurement were up to each individual country, that any of those countries would see a single dose before, say, Belgium reached 100% vaccination?


The answer is in the post you comment: Israel did it.


By having the best distribution system in the world, and by leveraging that into a promise to gather data on vaccine efficacy before anyone else can.

This trick only works for one small wealthy country. Nobody cares so much about the second fastest set of vaccination health data that they will prioritize shipments to your country. Slovakia and Greece would still be shit out of luck.

It's like pointing at a lottery winner, and saying - 'look, this is the strategy you all should be emulating to get out of poverty.' The problem is, there is only one winner, and there is only one guinea pig of a country that will commit itself to being a case study for a fast, full rollout, as long as it gets priority on vaccines.

Also, Israel's impressive vaccination statistics conveniently ignore its Palestinian population, which is not getting those doses.




Consider applying for YC's Fall 2025 batch! Applications are open till Aug 4

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: