Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

I've been living in the USA for 3 months now, and he doesn't mention the thing I find most surprising / disturbing / worrying / uncomfortable, which is the amazingly strong correlation between wealth and skin colour. Sure, this exists in S America where I was living before, but I expected better in the "first world".


The Civil Rights act wasn't even 50 years ago. Exactly how does this surprise you?

Incidentally: you want to see that correlation in Europe? Go for a walk in the Paris suburbs.


Heh. That reminds me. The other thing that surprised me is just how complacent Americans are about the inequality.


Or Turks and Germans in Germany.


FWIW, I think the US has the wealthiest population of African or African decedents in the world. Of course this may be simply a function of the average wealth of the US.

On the other hand, I think you will see the same kind of skin color based wealth stratification in every country in the world, developed or not.


> I've been living in the USA for 3 months now, and he doesn't mention the thing I find most surprising / disturbing / worrying / uncomfortable, which is the amazingly strong correlation between wealth and skin colour.

Are you referring to the Indians or the Asians?


I agree to a certain extent, but even more disconcerting is the difference between blacks from Britain and Americans who are black. The British have a confidence and ease of manner which is sadly not present with their American counterparts. It's as if black Americans are constantly looking over their shoulders and don't believe they are secure to be themselves. I see no trace of this in blacks from Europe.


This stuff is making me cringe. "Black Americans" aren't looking over their shoulders. People from a pervasive underclass are acting in ways society has conditioned to, whether they're black families living in a rowhouse in Englewood or white families living in a shack in Missouri.

I live in one of the most "segregated" cities in the United States, literally on one of its fault lines (my alley divides White Suburban Chicago from Black Urban Chicago). White or black, the people on my block are confident and secure and happy and generally pissed off or insecure about the same things I am; meanwhile, the people across the alley are living amongst dogfighting rings, hand-to-hand retail drug dealing, and flashing blue police cameras.

It's not a "black" and "white" thing and it's naive to express surprise about it. We all know how it got to be that way. There is no magic wand you can wave to lift 115,000 people out of social, educational, and economic poverty. Except maybe, maybe, by pouring billions of dollars into their public schoools.


I'm sorry you misunderstood. I was only giving my observations on the difference between blacks from Europe and America.


Please stop referring to "blacks"? I swear to God it's not PC-ness that's prompting this comment; it's my nerdy inability not to bristle at a sentence that misunderstands something so fundamentally.


OK? And what term would you use?


I would avoid generalizing about black people in America. You might be thinking about "the black urban underclass". Those people are very different from "black investment bankers".


Good point. My ancecdotal comments were refering to upper middle class people.


Then I call total BS, because no upper middle class black person that I know is "constantly looking over their shoulder", at least not in any way that upper middle class white people do already.

I'm going to be done discussing this now; I'm happy to read anything you write in response, but this is one of those super-unproductive discussions that is inevitably going to embarrass me in a year.


Europe still has plenty of behind-the-back discrimination of ethnic groups though, and conversely I think people in the UK have an ease of manner about saying racist things. America is very confrontational about it's racism, for better or worse.


My experience in Europe has been that the discrimination is much more out in the open than in the US. Maybe the response isn't.




Consider applying for YC's Fall 2025 batch! Applications are open till Aug 4

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: