Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Shouldn't the one responsible personally have to pay for it rather than the city and its taxpayers?



Do you have to pay the damages for every mistake you make at your job?


How on earth do you attribute responsibility here? Usually these things are an underfunded disaster waiting to happen, because the city can't find the money to upgrade from XP or whatever.


You mean the one who wrote the attacking code? Or the one who wrote the vulnerable code? Why do we even assume there is a "one" here?


Whoever made the decision not to take backups for example. The ones who will have to pay for their mistakes will be the taxpayers otherwise.


This is a public service, aren't the voters responsible? They could have voted in competent leaders.


This is it exactly. The voters are the ones who are ultimately responsible, and they'll be the ones to ultimately pay, just as it should be. They should be voting for competent leaders, and for sufficient taxes to pay decent salaries to attract good IT talent, but they don't, so this is what they get.

Every nation gets the government it deserves. - Joseph de Maistre


The voters are not one person. Sadly democracy ends up being the fascism of the many.


It sounds like you don't understand what "fascism" is, because this statement is plainly wrong.

The common statement is that "democracy is tyranny of the majority*, which is basically true IMO. Tyranny is not synonymous with fascism, though fascism can certainly be a form of tyranny.

Anyway, it doesn't matter if the voters aren't one person; they're a collective, and collectively they generally approve whatever government they're living under, or else they wouldn't have elected it, or allowed it to continue to rule them. If they elected it, they're getting what they voted for and what they deserve. If they didn't elect it, but allow it to rule them anyway, they're still getting what they deserve (though I'd make an exception for a small country being forcibly occupied by a much larger and more powerful country).




Consider applying for YC's Fall 2025 batch! Applications are open till Aug 4

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: