Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Yes, HuffPo is leftist, but I don't see how rage over this particular issue has jack-all to do with where you lie on the partisan spectrum. I'd expect even many full-bore libertarians to find that policy stupid, discriminatory or both (though they would more fully support an employer's right to be as stupid and discriminatory as they wish).


Stupid and discriminatory, they could probably agree on. The difference is in how they react.

Leftist: That's unfair! There ought to be a law.

Rightist: Meh, they probably have their reasons. Anyway, their funeral.


I think those characterizations are rather context-dependent, though. Restating my point somewhat differently, the "what should be done about it" reaction lies on a somewhat independent axis from the "how angry am I about this" reaction.

For example: A business that refused to hire gun owners would probably get a far more rage-filled reaction from a rightist than a leftist, but it's very roughly analogous.


I look at it as a self-correcting problem. It's a brain-dead stupid HR policy and firms that adopt brain-dead policies will eventually be beaten out by firms that don't.

And yes, I am a Libertarian. :-)


[deleted]


At the risk of turning this into a political argument... your characterization of the left is simply untrue. A 'leftist' (whatever that means) would most likely view business with a measure of caution, preferring a regulatory power keeping a careful (but generally distant) watch over those business practices.

Very few on 'the left' are full bore socialists, and even fewer are anti-commerce.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: