Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Signify is the first OpenBSD code that I've ever read from start to finish - (minus the external libraries like the Ed25519 package). Watching the initial checkins, followed by the amazing improvement in the command line options within a a few weeks of checking by external contributors - the final product is much, much better than the first checkin. What I really appreciate, is that they managed to strike a balance between keeping the tool 100% lean, and adding tiny bits of syntactic sugar (such as the Untrusted Comment field, and, the ability to simultaneously verify the SHA256 hash and signature of a list of files.)

Teaching people how to use the tool, from the point of generating keys, to generating signature manifests for a packages, to signing, and verifying takes < 3 minutes for someone who already knows what a hash is.

And, the complete absence of CA architecture, or web-of-trust - and an focus on sharing their (really short) public keys in a visible and widely distributed manner just makes the system so much simpler to understand.

For example - this literally is all you have to do on OS X to have a complete end-end signing/manifest/verification system:

Generate your keypair:

   signify -G -p pub -s sec
Your public key is tiny, and can be shared anywhere/everywhere:

  RWRGNg6NU+JAt9ju3ItQfOMmDhXmEkHp28mej8ickx4lOJjE2Tg2DxEO
Created your manifest (On OpenBSD you just go "sha256 file* ")

   shasum -a 256 file* | awk '{print "SHA256 ("$2") = "$1}'> manif
Sign your manifest, and embed the signature in the resulting sig file:

   signify -S -e -s sec -m manif -x manif.sig
And now, anybody who has your public key, can verify that manifest:

   signify -C  -p pub -x manif.sig
That's it, that's the entire system from beginning to end.



"... the complete absence of CA architecture, or web-of-trust..."


That decision eliminates a lot (50%, 75%, 90%?) of the complexity that comes with GPG and most CA architectures. It also means the keys can be typed in by hand.


Correct.




Consider applying for YC's Fall 2025 batch! Applications are open till Aug 4

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: