Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

There are good reasons to care about markets, though it needs to be recognized that markets serve humanity.

If you go to the Marxist extreme of a centrally planned economy people aren't taken into account.

If you go to the extreme of a completely unregulated free market economy people aren't taken into account.

The happy medium is a free market that's regulated to prevent coercive and abusive practices. The US had a much stronger overall economy and greater general prosperity when it followed that model. The neoliberal extremist policies that have been been adopted since the 80s have been a series of unfolding tragedies for the poor and middle class in the US.

Rent controls don't appear in a vacuum, they are a response to the unfolding human tragedies of rentier exploitation that harm actual people. They may not be optimally implemented in SF, but to label them Communist is extremist.

The neoliberal shock-treatment approach in Russia was a human disaster as well, and the horrors in Chile, parts of the EU, and elsewhere show why extremism that cares more about ideology than humanity is a vice. It doesn't matter if the ideologues are Marxists or Capitalists, ideologues always promote policies that are bad for humanity, since they care more about ideological purity than practicality or humanity.



Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: