Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

This seems like one of the most obvious media presses I've ever seen. I can't decide whether it's good to see the press that security is getting, and have the same terrible LE quotes show up, or bad that there is such widespread dissemination that LE is unhappy about this and hey if you're a good citizen you will buy a phone we can more easily unlock.

Here are the same or similar articles:

-WSJ 8[1] and 5[2] days ago

-Washington Post 5 Days ago[3]

-NYTimes 4 days ago[4]

-TIME 3 Days ago[5]

-Fortune 3 days ago [6]

[1] http://online.wsj.com/articles/new-level-of-smartphone-encry...

[2] http://online.wsj.com/articles/fbi-director-raises-concerns-...

[3] http://www.washingtonpost.com/politics/fbi-chief-new-phone-e...

[4] http://www.nytimes.com/2014/09/27/technology/iphone-locks-ou...

[5] http://time.com/3437222/iphone-data-encryption/

[6] http://fortune.com/2014/09/27/apple-and-the-fbi-re-enact-the...



Whether or not its a coordinated media blitz or just journalists piggybacking on each other for content I don't know. That it is coming out at the same time new iPhones could go either way.

Things that people are completely missing about this story: -Big difference between domestic & local law enforcement and NSA/DoD/CIA. Nothing prevents backdooring of a phone or someone spying as the user enters their simple password. Local law enforcement doesn't have these resources and has gotten used to access to all kinds of evidence that never existed. What Apple may or may not have done just pushes the cost up.

-I think Apple is very scared about being locked out of the Chinese market right now. The new iPhones have not been approved yet last I heard. This is a big fucking deal that would wipe out a huge chunk of Apple's market cap. They are not going to budge because some local law enforcement officers claim only child molesters use iPhones.

-Google is in a similar boat except they are already locked out of China, likely will get locked out of Russia soon. They would like to be able to still make money in Brazil and the EU.

-I think it is a good trend for the pushback from tech companies. There is no good answer for international legal compliance for user records. Records should be accessible once an account has been compromised locally, not because any judge in any country on earth can search all of your user data on any user in any other country. Between Dropbox, Dropcam & all of these other cloud services, right now a user has no idea who has access to all of their data all of the time. Time travel back two decades, no one is stealing all of your data over a dial up modem. Nor is a device recording every square foot of where you are at every moment. The tools law enforcement have access to right now are godlike


Stories need to be in the queue longer than the rate these were published by different news desks. This is obviously a PR push by skilled people placing stories. That is PR, public relations, press relations, people have a full time jobs getting stories placed.

I'd really like to see the government NOT be able to hire PR firms. This is propaganda.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: