Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

It’s good that the weather is really gentle now in Hong Kong.

Here in Ukraine this past winter the “designed in California” didn’t last too long during -13C..-18C nights, even with an external battery, so walkie-talkies were helpful at times. However, the cellular networks did work in the downtown, perhaps with just minor outages, even during the most violent crackdowns.

And to address some of the either Russian trolls or just misinformed minds elsewhere in the comments. I won’t go into much details, just address some points.

- The whole situation in Ukraine was, and is, largely provoked and inflamed by Russia. Empires being what empires are, even fading ones, try to concur and/or influence as much neighbours as possible, especially if a neighbour is posing an indirect threat to the empire’s regime rulers. No need to take my word on it, just study recent conflicts around Russian borders since the 90s.

- All sorts of people, from all kinds of backgrounds, education, income, etc, took part in the protests. From poor farmers and peasants, through students and professors, to entrepreneurs, CEOs of big companies/multinational branches, and other well-off people.

- To call all these people “fascists”, “junta”, is something a Gebbels would do. Especially when coming from a state that has extreme press and internet censorship, where all the power lies in the hands of the state security service, and where sexual/national minorities live under real threat and danger of persecution. Especially ridiculously it sounds given the number of Jews, and well-off ones, taking parts in the protests, alongside the so-called “radicals”.

- Somebody mentioned “Svoboda” and “Pravyj Sektor” as boogeymen. “Svoboda” has like 1% support now; it lost the support greatly during the protests themselves, when people found out that their “radicalism” is only in words, but not in action. The leadership is very money-oriented, and it shows. Regular members are more or less OK, as members political parties go; most are just regular patriots, like you have in the US and elsewhere. “Pravyj Sektor” is really just a bunch of kids; we’ve bought them socks and some underwear during the winter. Aren’t any more radical than most kids their age anywhere in the world.

- Russian propaganda was working very hard all these years against the Ukrainian state, but as we can see, it took root only in some parts of the 2, out of 25, regions. The reasons are simple - these are very “depressed”, poor regions; people live there in constant poverty, without decent jobs, repressed by local feudal lords, without proper education and perspective on life. This is not an excuse for what they’ve started, but at least it explains the causes. In other, considered “pro-Russian” but wealthy, regions the propaganda didn’t take as much root, and after the events of this year, there’s little left of the “pro-Russian” part in them, even as they continue to speak Russian in everyday life.

- As for the West, we’ve seen who’s who now, and what they are worth. That was a hard yet an important lesson. We are learning to rely only on ourselves, and we’ll manage. Also, given that Ukraine has given up the world’s 3rd largest nuclear arsenal in 1994, in exchange for security guarantees, it will be a good lesson for other countries for the future. One which will probably not help improve the global demilitarisation, however.

Thank you for reading, and please excuse the long post.

P.S. Didn’t find my old “Startup News” account credentials, not really much of a poster, but decided not skip this one thread.



Thanx for your reply!

You know, it is very hard here to form an opinion on these things (Netherlands), we never ever see anything Putin says, we just have conflicting messages in and outside of the news (like http://www.elsevier.nl/Cultuur--Televisie/achtergrond/2014/9...), the article is about how our news organizations manipulated Putins words. We also hear 30 min after a plane is shot down that the Russians did it. And we hear Assad fired chemical weapons (he didn't but that is given much less attention to.)

Assad has been calling the rebels terrorists all along (http://www.globalresearch.ca/bashar-al-assad-interview-the-f...) but we were supporting them? But now we don't anymore... What are we supposed to think of all this! It drives me crazy.

Makes me not just want to call Putin a bad guy, I simply don't know and can't trust the news.

So I highly appreciate your insights in these matters.


>So I highly appreciate your insights in these matters.

it isn't an insight. It is propaganda.


The first two paragraphs are useful contribution to discussion. The rest is... well, useless.

"...when people found out that their “radicalism” is only in words, but not in action."

So, you ditched them because they were not radical? If you're gonna rant, at least do it right. We get it, you're being fucked from all sides. Welcome to reality. Other than that, you forgot to mention over 30 volunteer battalions like Aidar that, according to Amnesty International, "have been involved in widespread abuses, including abductions, unlawful detention, ill-treatment, theft, extortion, and possible executions."

http://www.amnesty.org/en/library/asset/EUR50/040/2014/en/bb...


Are you suggesting that the Russian "Empire" is more influential in Ukraine than the US Empire? :P

Or maybe that the West doesn't spew propaganda too? :)


As we joke here, if the CIA gave the world the internet, the KGB gave it the internet trolls. Try harder, @teekert, link-spamming buddy.


Teekert gave a link to back up what they said, unlike you with your almost anonymous account and smarmy attitude. Ukraine just substituted one oligarchy for another but the current one has Western support ( IMF debt ). I agree with the perception of heavy Western news bias which is not credible. No credibility for the cursing Nuland handing out cookies, violent Kiev street thugs, and Kiev junta bombing their own people. It is not just 2 regions, remember Crimea voted for autonomy and no one is rioting to return to the Ukraine junta. And I'm not Russian, just US resident who is partly Latino who knows how the gringos operate. KGB jokes are pretty old you should update your humor, especially as KGB predate the Internet.


In the internet age as in any other time in history, whoever controls the communication channels win.

For now IMO the winners are: Google, Facebook, Twitter, Apple(on the top but sliding down?), Amazon, US Gov, NSA, CIA, FBI, KGB, Russian Gov, Chinese Gov (win by block out others), Badu, Alibaba, WeChat, Line, SnapChat,

For now, the losers or losing players are : Yahoo, Nokia, Windows Phone, BlackBerry, Liberian Gov, Ukraine, Egypt(almost?), Most of Japanese Electronic firms.


you forgot that behind all those are financial firms like Goldman Sachs.

without their fake money schemes Facebook for example would only have it's revenue money, which is pretty lower than all the investment money they have.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: