you very solidly supported the argument you are against.

"Hey Joe, can you move the report to the share?"

is a great way to communicate something you want done. it doesnt matter if its to a computer, a person, or a dog. If it can't operate on those bounds then its not sophisticated enough to actually meet the needs of the user. One day computers will get there, they haven't done so not because its a 'bad way to talk to a computer' but because computers have not yet become that sophisticated.