Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

The government isn't censoring information here, citizens are.

Any explicit mention of "there is censored information" would mean Google are back in court.

I honestly doubt any big scandal can be hidden by removing it from Google. Scandals spread virally, ear to ear (i.e. social networks, digital or not). This is more useful so embarrassing or false information can't prevent normal folks from getting a job and so on.



The government is absolutely the force of censorship here. These requests to be forgotten only have any teeth because the government backs them with its ability to punish Google if they fail to comply with them.


Yes, and the government has teeth because it is backed by its citizens. You could probably argue that the main force from governments comes from police and other armed force, but this is not what found their legitimacy. And most people in Europe, for historical and deep-rooted cultural reasons, seem to be in favor of the ruling. So all is well!


The government has teeth because it ultimately has the threat of violence over the governed. That's what "law enforcement" is.

A government's legitimacy comes from the consent of the governed, but its power comes from the threat of force. If that wasn't true, then there would be no need for government, since people could just ask nicely for what they want and receive it without any need to coerce others into doing it under threat of forced deprivation of assets or liberty.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: