Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

I've never used this site or UStream because I don't understand what I'm looking at.

I just clicked on a video on Justin.tv's front page. I was shown a 3-second intro, and then a woman appeared, introduced herself and started talking.

Internal monologue: "Is this live? pre-recorded? I have no clue. The site seems to be about live video, but if so, how did I manage to tune in right as she was introducing herself?"

I refresh the page. See the intro again, and the video starts from the same point as before.

So it's not live. It's pre-recorded video...

Why wouldn't I just watch this on Youtube?

What am I missing here? The user experience on both of these sites seems really bizarre. They tell me I'm going to watch some live video...and link me to a bunch of pre-recorded stuff. It's bewildering.




Everything on Justin.tv is live video.

We do feature live video on the front page, but we can only show one live stream at a time and still be comprehensible. So we have to have things like our directory page:

http://www.justin.tv/directory

to list all of the live video on the site.


Everything featured on the top half of the front page on http://ustream.tv/ is live. Below that there are highlights, and upcoming events, both clearly marked. When watching a live stream, the watermark in the top right corner says Live, if it's a recorded video it says Pre-Recorded. The thing is, you are not going to find this content on youtube, as it was all captured live on either service.


I believe that Ustream actually offers an export-to-YouTube feature.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: