Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

From the video it seems like it's a social network for questions.

Sorry for the negativity, but I can't see how this would work. It suffers from the same problem as every social network does, people need to be on it. If I want to get responses from my friends instead of just googling it, I go to my biggest social network Facebook to get those. I just don't see any value in this, it doesn't solve a problem any better than the current alternatives do.




From the page: "Jelly works with your existing social networks."

My understanding was that it works as an addon to facebook or twitter or whatever. Maybe one of the creators is floating around here and can clear this up.


Seems like the landing page is full of fluff. All I see are feel good sentences about helping each other, Albert Einstein, etc.

The big down side is this: "“What’s this?” That query is submitted to some people in your network who also have Jelly".

I have +400 friends on Facebook. Out of those, maybe 3 will install Jelly to try it out. Even with taking friends-of-friends taken in to consideration, it's just a very limited set of people. Would I really want to use this app to post a question that I can probably find answer just by looking a map, doing a google search or posting to Facebook/Twitter?


> In a world where 140 characters is considered a maximum length, a picture really is worth a thousand words.

What a silly world these people live in.


I'm following a lot of Twitter and other SF tech people on Twitter, and I had tons of questions waiting. Maybe it will stick for a some people, but indeed, I don't think most people have enough questions to check this kind of app often.


I believe it implements Facebook Connect and the Twitter Followers API, as with nearly every startup since the social networking boom in 2008.

EDIT: The app uses friends of friends on Facebook, and also the Twitter Followings of your Facebook Friends.




Consider applying for YC's Fall 2025 batch! Applications are open till Aug 4

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: