Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

Well there's this:

    > What about clinical studies?
    > Clinical studies will be published soon, showing the same
    > dramatic improvements in plaque-removal and overall oral
    >  hygiene that our inhouse testing and usage by 
    > our first customers have already been showing.

That's not quite how science works.

But it's nice to see engineering geeks getting into the medical quackery business.

Also:

> It lasts 1 year - you receive a refurbished one (professionally cleaned and all bristles brandnew) for 89.

So it's even more expensive to maintain than an electric toothbrush, which can also be shared among multiple users with different bristle heads.




[deleted]


Bob brushes more carefully with NEW STYLE BRUSH than he does with OLD STYLE BRUSH, thus leading people to think that the new brush is better. When actually, it isn't, because it misses the gum line and doesn't help prevent gum disease. Thus, the population using the new brush has more fillings, extractions, deaths from surgery, and deaths from heart disease associated with gum disease.

There's a reason science is rigorous.


I feel like this effect is diminished when you're brushing your teeth in front of a researcher.

Also, don't forget that the NEW STYLE BRUSH you mention is more likely to be improperly used.


> I'm not certain why you believe that you need to run double blind clinical trials on a tooth brush

Double blind means that neither the researcher nor the subject knows which device the subject got.

I don't think that this is possible (he said, with some understatement) when comparing a standard toothbrush to a bristly mouth guard thing.


Yeah, you don't need a double blind study here... Just measure the plaque levels before and after usage.

As long as the plaque reductions are comparable, as well as the absolute final values, you're golden.

Looks like the savings is about 6 days over 5 years (http://xkcd.com/1205/). At a cost of $900 that's not a bad return on investment.


One important aspect of tooth brushing is gum stimulation, which is harder to measure than plaque removal.


I've been plagued with bad teeth all my life. No one ever taught me to know your teeth are clean, you just gotta figure it out. Who cares what toothbrush gets you there as long as it makes your life easier? It's not like it's a chemical.




Join us for AI Startup School this June 16-17 in San Francisco!

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: