Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

No toilet, and no way to get off, or even really stand up? I know some personal jets lack such facilities, but they're not exactly open to the public. At least on BART you can move away from the crazy...



No toilets on commuter buses either and people ride them 45minutes to 1+ hours everyday with no issues.

You're stuck in the "long trip" "it's like a train" framework.

It is neither.


The distance is just about what I commuted on a bus for many, many years, also with no facilities.

In peak hour it would probably be fine, when everyone is fairly sensible and not drunk. But after hours, I've had quite a few uncomfortable bus rides due to the various anti-social behaviours of fellow passengers. That was with the hand-brake of a driver who obviously isn't getting involved, but can avoid escalating behaviour by stopping the bus or calling authorities.

I have great faith in the technology! I just wish I had as much faith in the people riding inside it :)


Commuter buses stop regularly.


The commuter busses in NYC don't have bathrooms. For instance the X1 bus goes 45 minutes non-stop:

Schedule: http://www.mta.info/nyct/bus/schedule/xpress/x001cur.pdf


I visited my friend in New York, and he took the express from Staten Island to Manhattan, and it was ~45 minutes without any stops (from the last Staten Island one to the first Manhattan one)


Taxi rides, flights, buses all have 30 min rides FREQUENTLY and no washroom facilities in those 30 min.


The paper mentions two tube diameters, supporting "more versatile" Hyperloop capsules in the larger version.

Also, with a 35-minute trip time, these concerns are well within the realm of "hold it" till the next stop.


> No toilet, and no way to get off, or even really stand up?

Seriously? It's like laying in a not quite horizontal bed for 30 minutes. If you can't plan your bathroom usage 30 minutes ahead of time, then don't use this transportation system (or wear a diaper). I can almost always hold it for 30 minutes after I am really feeling the urge to go. With 12-14 million trips per year, will there be accidents? Certainly. So that capsule gets diverted to be cleaned. Big deal.

> At least on BART you can move away from the crazy

It looks like those spaces are small enough that only 1 person could easily interact with you. If that's a problem, they could probably build in plastic dividers. Or you could just buy two tickets. If you can't tolerate that level of risk, then again, don't ride this thing.

I can assure you that there are plenty of people who are not bothered by these issues.


You can't get out of your seat during take off or landing on commercial plane either, and that easily takes 30+ minutes.


LA -> SF in 30 minutes. Why would you need a toilet?


Unless it breaks down. In which case the "toilet" question might become quite pressing, quite quickly.


That issue holds for lots of modes of transportation (BART, buses, gridlocked traffic...)


it's a 35 min commute so those things are not necessarily required. Amenities can be built outside the boarding station




Consider applying for YC's Fall 2025 batch! Applications are open till Aug 4

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: