Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Hmm so a kind of liberal vs. socialist philosophy of technology. You just gave me a new perspective on things. Thanks!


I'd suggest checking out Wikipedia, Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy, and Encyclopedia Britannica on the term "communitarianism". It's far more relevant than applying the word "socialist" without meaning.


That depends what you put in that word. To me socialism is not a bad thing.


To me, socialism isn't meaningfully comparable to liberalism. It's apples and oranges.


Well then you need to change your perspective I guess. Of course it's comparable. They are both political systems.


Socialism isn't a political system. Neither, come to that, is liberalism. Socialism is an economic system. Liberalism is a political philosophy.

How about, instead of using labels like "liberal vs socialist" to express your point, you actually describe what you mean? Because you clearly haven't conveyed the contrast between Engelbart and the "younger programmers" that you wanted to.


Socialism is as much a political philosophy and system as it is an economic system.

You seem to like Wikipedia, so I suggest you go read up on it.

And please read what was actually written.

I was not expressing a point I was thanking someone for giving me a new perspective on things.

Whether your understanding of the words socialism & liberalism allow you to understand that is really not of my concern.


entirely not such a gross simplification


hence the expression "kind of"




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: