Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

Given all the anecdotes around here offering the same experience, I'm interested in this too. If it is a cultural thing, I'd say two things:

1. It makes sense. A lot of sense. In the real world, it's far more useful to be able to collaborate effectively than to always adopt an adversarial or competitive attitude.

2. It should be addressed openly. Personally, I think a more collaborative environment would help a lot of us in a lot of ways, but sometimes that's just not how things are supposed to be done (e.g. assignments and tests in most US schools); in that case, everyone might be a little more aware and happy if it were clear up front -- in very multi-cultural situations -- what the expectations are regarding individual work.

Of course, that won't stop everyone, and it doesn't address every problem, but making everyone aware of the differences could stop a lot of misunderstanding and, potentially, what's technically cheating even though that may not be the intent.

[edit: Of course, some people do just plain cheat, knowingly and willfully; this is not intended to excuse that behavior, which is crap and should be punished.]




I think the Code Jam incident is an example of knowingly and willfully cheating. It is obvious that you are supposed to be competing individually.

Even in the event that that isn't obvious, why signup for 3 accounts? Why not just signup for a team account and play as a team?


I was more replying to the other post (as Google hasn't actually said anything yet), but if it is as presented, then yeah, there's no excuse for it.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: