Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Aside: Why "Indian coders" and not just "Three coders"? Would this have ever been titled "white coders found cheating"? I know this isn't the point of the article, but I wonder if, on HN, we should consider clipping "gratuitous adjectives" in titles that contribute to perpetuating dominant systems.


They are from the country named India. Thus Indian coders. Color has nothing to do with it. If they were from America the title would not have been white coders but American coders.


I can absolutely accept that distinction. Do you think "American coders" would have been the title if that were the case?


If the host were not an American company, perhaps. Not all news is world news, though


Probably because that's the demographic the site was created to serve: NextBigWhat is an Indian tech blog, focusing on Indian startups and the Indian tech ecosystem. Their "About" page has a few quotes calling themselves the "Techcrunch of India."


From what my friends have told me, corruption and cheating is much more culturally accepted in India. So although race has no place being in a conversation, culture is relevant to the discussion. Also, white is not a culture, race, or country of origin, why would you put that in the title anyway?


So we are going to ban facts now?

The problem is that it does seem to be cultural. In every one of my computer science classes, students from India almost always shared answers on the test, copied each others' homework, and felt there was no problem with it.


I always wonder what happens to all these honest Americans once they get into Wall Street. Or these days Silicon Valley where keeping people addicted to social feeds and video streams is making an honest living. Let not even talk about the guys who sold the rest of the world on WMD's.


"I always wonder what happens to all these honest Americans once they get into Wall Street."

The rest probably get filtered out well before reaching that point.


2 wrongs don't make a right. If we choose to ignore a problem that continues to happen because we want to be more PC, it will never stop.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: