Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

Foxglove for heart disease. FDA approved and doctors don't recommend it enough.



Foxglove is a really silly idea as a herbal medicine because it is available in a quantified purified form from the pharmacy called digoxin and you will minimise the change of running out of the very narrow therapeutic window that digoxin is both efficacious and non-toxic within.

Side effects of digitalis (the active component) toxicity include but are not limited to DEATH

Saying take foxglove instead of digitalis is kind of like saying take willow bark instead of aspirin, but potentially MUCH MORE DANGEROUS.

If what you mean to say is 'we shiuldnt give profits to the pharmaceutical-medical-industrial complex because I believe it is acting against my best interests' then go ahead and say so; however if thr best example of an 'alternative' medicine being efficacious or safer is foxglove you are woefully underinformed

As the saying goes, alternative medicine that works becomes medicine. That is digoxin


The FDA recognizes foxglove as a toxin, not a treatment [1]. You don't want to consume foxglove because, like virtually all herbal supplements, the doses of the active ingredient can vary wildly.

So, we have its derivative, digoxin, available as a prescription medication. And many people do take it. It's helpful for some symptoms of heart failure. One thing it doesn't do, quite notably, is reduce mortality. Anyway, this is an available, commonly prescribed treatment

Not to belabor the point, but I was hoping to hear about alternative medicines that are not accepted but have evidence supporting them.

[1] = http://www.accessdata.fda.gov/scripts/plantox/detail.cfm?id=...




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: