As stated elsewhere in the thread, this is a clever retort but in practice defined? is the only major example I've seen where the ? suffix results in a non-boolean return value. You're arguing over a convention, and I think most people writing Ruby would be surprised to learn defined? returns a String.
It's a common misconception that ruby developers think that predicates must return a boolean value. It's still a misconception. This blog post linked elsewhere in the discussion is a good summary: http://blog.leshill.org/blog/2012/03/25/a-question-of-truth....
Another notable example is nonzero? which returns the value of the number if nonzero and nil otherwise:
