Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

It's way more nuanced than this. Ultimately poverty comes down to an individual's ability to be self-sustaining.

Take a software engineer, take away their house, job, and all of their money so they are homeless and have literally nothing ("broke"): how quickly can they reach a stable self-sustaining state again?

Probably pretty quickly:

- Ask family for help (they are anchored in a higher place to help bootstrap you up again - borrow some money, temporarily move back in with parents, etc)

- Get a new programming job

- Build a small nest egg

- Done, back to a self-sustaining state in a short time frame

Now take a kid from Baltimore who dropped out of high school and who has no skills. Repeat the scenario

- Ask family for help (they probably aren't in much of a position to help - they can't pull you up when they aren't anchored in a higher place)

- Get a new job (good luck when you have few marketable skills. The high(er) paying jobs for people with no marketable skills usually involve selling drugs/sex)

- Can't build a nest egg easily

Poverty (in the USA at least) is mainly a product of your family situation and your knowledge/marketable skills. If you have an unstable family and no marketable skills, escaping poverty is extremely difficult without an external actor helping to pull people up.





What stopped the baltimore kid from getting any valuable/marketable skills? Why did he drop school? In the end, it's a sum of all their little personal decisions. Sure, family and environment play their important role, but it's still personal fault.

> The high(er) paying jobs

What about low paying jobs? I’m sure some people on minimum wage have netflix - which automatically makes them non-poor according to TFA.


I see the steps. What if they have no family members or they do not give a damn?

Start again please from the state of being homeless but assume this person has no family members, or has relatives, but they do not give a damn.

It crumbles, IMO.


Maybe you didn't read the whole comment?

I dunno if that last sentence was there when I made the comment...



Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: