Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Quick anecdote before I dive in:

>learning things like how to run an Airbnb or food truck, manage a brokerage account or Broadway production, or build a business or drone.

I remember touring my high school alma mater, a local magnet with a decent record of getting kids into top schools (that it was fed by the bedroom communities of NASA and USDA sites clearly notwithstanding). As we passed the shop, we spent a good 15 minutes learning about the small plane students were building. A good 10-foot wingspan. I matriculated and that was the last I heard of it.

I've noticed that, in marketing for educational institutions, it's common for the uncommon and exceptional achievements of That One Student to get pushed as indicative of what most students can expect to (and will never actually) do. I'd think most would do well to be wary of an article that starts out with such a claim. Regression to the mean probably factors in, even for outlier schools.



And he's an AI guy pushing AI things in an AI hype cycle.

That said, some combination of AI + Wikipedia could probably do amazing things for teaching a student. Here's the thing: if the student trusts that he can ask any stupid question to an AI, a well trained one can probably walk students through concepts in any of thousands of different questions asked by previous students and lead them through to the end goal.

I can see the potential.

But these guys? No. Education should be humanist, not capitalist. You can already see it: look at the little entrepreneur parrots we created. This isn't education to benefit the child: it's marketing to the parents to get them to pay up because their precious child will become the next Bill Gates.


He is not AI guy. SalesBuilder is a constraint solver, not AI, not even an expert system.


From the article though, Joe Liemandt and an AI enthusiast now and funding a lot of work on educational software assuming AI is the answer.

The software alone seems not to be the answer, though.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: