Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

>Or as a question: Why can't we do that stuff?

Because over the past decades the interests that used to focus on growing the pie have pivoted to scooping up more of the pie (usually by getting government, or government adjacent entity, to pull some string).

Imagine the year is 1950/60/70/80 and you are a lobbyist for a construction product manufacture. What do you tell your paid off political to vote for? Stuff that lowers cost, creates more development, etc, of course. Because for every mil spent industry wide you know your employer nets $10, or whatever.

In 2025 you'd wine and dine a bunch of IBC jerks and insurance jerks and maybe even government jerks to get them to phrase things so that the industry is "incentivized" to use your employer's class of products, to the detriment of literally every participant in your sector for whom a different class of product would have otherwise been superior in their situation.

This sort of pivot to zero sum behavior has permeated damn near every class of economic activity, only in the most cutting edge spots of cutting edge sectors and the lowest margin, lowest sophistication, lowest security/moat sectors do you see anyone lift a goddamn finger to grow the pie.



The tragedy of free market is that once a player achieves a dominant position, they will have the resources to change the rules so that the market is no longer free.


The true tragedy of free market is that we keep blaming it while in reality all we have is a market artificially influenced by lobbyists, governmental overreach and corruption.

Until you have laws favouring one entity over another, it is not a free market.


I think you almost got what I was saying: once the winners emerge, they have the money to lobby laws in their favor.


> once the winners emerge, they have the money to lobby laws in their favor.

Only works in a flawed democracy, in better democracies people vote out corrupt leaders that only listen to lobbyists.


This better democracy sounds wonderful.

I've also heard that in real communism everyone gets their needs met and anarchism would let the true human nature flourish and everyone would be happy. I'm sure one day we will habe a society of better people who will make all of these work.




Consider applying for YC's Winter 2026 batch! Applications are open till Nov 10

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: