Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Um not down voting you, but your argument has some flaws.

Firstly your appeal to authority , and then using Steve Ballmer as your authority is perhaps not the best way to start.

Secondly you say that "no professional programmer" - but the statement is false. For starters it's a sweeping generalization which is trivial to show is untrue for at least 1 programmer.

Thirdly the existence of Open Source alternatuve does not make a product uncompetitive. You need look no further than Windows to see that's true. Indeed if we has to list all the commercial software that exists with an Ooen Source clone, we'd be here all day. I'd also argue that Joe public doesn't even know what open source is, much less factors it into a buying decision.

If you are building tools for programmers (already a tiny niche target market) then you need a hook other than Open Source anyway, cause programmers are a terrible target market.

I say this as someone who builds tools for programmers, and who sells commercial into a space that contains Open Source alternatives. And I do ok.



Quoting Steve Ballmer doesn't mean that the person is worshipping Steve Ballmer as a god. It just means that another person expressed a similar opinion.


You can't add color to your argument if you've failed to add an argument. If all you've typed is an appeal to authority, you're trying to trick people into making your argument for you by trying to guess what Ballmer meant and why he thought that.

Instead of getting people to try and come up with an argument that wasn't made, the argument could have just been made. But I'm sure it is a very bad argument, or else there wouldn't be that embarrassment to try.


Nobody has appealed to authority. Quoting a person is not appealing to authority. And why would anybody be embarrassed about anything here?




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: