Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

>yes I do believe this administration is completely and sincerely focused on Israel and the interests of Israel

100%, and I completely agree with you. This administration seems positively subservient to Israel.

But they don't care an iota about antisemitism. Many in Trump's circle are infamous antisemites. It has long been an observation that Trump is pro-Israel yet paradoxically simultaneously an antisemite. Trump himself seems to view Jewishness as being loyal only to Israel -- he has quite literally stated this -- and that those that aren't loyal to Israel are not actually Jews. Trump has frequently repeated stereotypes and caricatures about Jews.

I don't for a moment think Trump cares an iota about antisemitism, even though I think he's a strong ally of Israel. Which is fair because it's possible to be critical of Israel without being an antisemite. The simple conflation of the two -- as this administration does -- is itself antisemitism. I conflates Jews worldwide as mere vassals of Israel.



Antisemitism is largely becoming an irrelevant word because of how it's weaponized to prevent criticism of Israel. At this point in time many Jews would be considered antisemitic with how it's used, especially Ultra Orthodox who tend to view the existence of Israel (the current political entity) as blasphemous for reasons outside the scope of this post. It's also somewhat a dumb term given that e.g. Palestinians are Semites.

In any case I think Trump cares about things like preventing violence/intimidation against Jews. And I do think that's a reasonable concern. A certain political orientation in the US has become increasingly violent over the years and as Jews (which are distinct from the Israeli government) fall out of fashion with them, concerns of a progression towards violence are not entirely unfounded. By contrast, I do not think he cares about things like memes of long nosed bankers rubbing their hands or claims Jews are more loyal to Israel than the US.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: