Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

The difference between terrorists and freedom fighters is whether they're aligned with my views. When it's the government making the distinction, the difference is whether they're aligned with the government's views.


No it's not. The main difference is that terrorists target civilian population as a means to get what they want, and freedom fighters target military.


Furthermore, a rebellion or freedom fighters in a moral framework is when you have an authoritarian regime, aka “the monster that comes for us all” (Andor S2) that needs to be overcome.

An authoritarian regime has no representation of the population, has no need for feedback, and is ruled by a few. In the work of Thomas Payne he says “When all rights have been taken away, the right of rebellion has been made perfect.”


Name me one war that didn't target civilians...


what's it called when military targets civilians to get what they want?


War. It's called war. In ye olden days, military forces pillaged farms (for food) and sacked cities (for loot). Rarely, there have been short eras of formalized military v military conflicts within various cultures, but this was not the norm. In more modern times, military forces destroys enemy infrastructure to degrade their ability to make war directly target civilians to reduce the # of enemies and hurt morale (supposedly). While sad, one of the facts of life is that war leads to civilian deaths. Usually far more than direct military deaths.


>While sad, one of the facts of life is that war leads to civilian deaths. Usually far more than direct military deaths.

Fair play to the Ukrainian forces who are doing a fantastic job of minimising Civilian deaths. Road map for the future[?]


It's a bad analogy. What if the civilians are themselves perpetuating the regime's views without any sort of independent thinking?


It's not an analogy, it's the dictionary definition.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: