Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

It’s not correct to say that lasers are unreliable. Last year more than 20M transceivers shipped. Your statement is not at all supported by real field failure data.

The reliability of micro LEDs. and specifically GaN based micro LEDs is however an open question.

In the absence of any dislocation failure mechanisms it will depend on the current density and thermal dissipation. And just like any other material, it will have to survive in a non-hermetic environment and in the presence of corrosive gasses (an issue in data centers).

To get the 10G, it’s probably kind of like a VCSEL without the grating and so current density is probably high. How well you’re able to heat sink it is going to determine how reliable it will be.

Overall I like the idea. It looks like the beachfront could work. I’d spend more time talking about and how the electrical connection works and what kind of interface to a chip would be needed.

I’d also be careful before throwing shade on laser reliability because it could backfire on you (for all reasons above).



Haha, given that he is the founder of Kaiam and Santur I think he has the credentials to throw shade.


You made an account just to respond?

Generally it’s a good idea to sell what’s good about your product and not say things that are not true about other peoples products.

Also I wouldn’t brag about Kaiam.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: