Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Why don't photons have a position operator?


It’s really not accurate to say that a photon has no position at all. How would a photodiode work? You have to be careful with this stuff. https://physics.stackexchange.com/questions/492711/whats-the...


Photons certainly appear to have a real physical location with 1e9 FPS imaging capabilities:

"Visualizing video at the speed of light — one trillion frames per second" (2012) https://youtube.com/watch?v=EtsXgODHMWk&

But is there an identity function for a photon(s), and is "time-polarization" necessary for defining an identity function for photons?


Think of it like this: From the perspective of the photon, it lives and dies in the same instant. Even if it traveled across the entire universe.

Since it lives and dies in the same instant, it can't have a position—because the moment it exists and the moment it doesn't is exactly the same time.

It takes time—even for light—to get from point A to point B. However, the measurement of any positions—relative to the photon itself—will always be the same. It's related to that property of quantum physics that allows two particles to exists in two different places at the same time.


> > > Mathematically a photon is defined as a state of the EM field (which has been quantised into a set of harmonic oscillators called "normal modes") in which there is exactly one quantum of excitation of a specific normal mode (with given wavevector and frequency). Depending on which kind of modes you consider, a photon could be a gaussian beam, or even a plane wave, so not something localised like you would say of a particle.

> Think of it like this: From the perspective of the photon, it lives and dies in the same instant. Even if it traveled across the entire universe.

Would an appropriate analogy be a "glider" from Conway's Game of Life? "Lives and dies in the same instant" isn't exactly the same, but I'm thinking of how no parts of the glider move while the glider as a whole "moves" across the board.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: