Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

The Tree of Life was one of the only films I’ve ever considered walking out of, I hated every moment of it. I’m delighted to hear you were spellbound by it.





I actually walked out of it. I was not alone, several others did before me.

I saw it without knowing what it was about, it was a summer evening, I was alone and just decided to see a movie as I passed the theatre.

When I came home and learned it was the same director as the Thin Red Line, I was blown away. Same director of both the best and the worst movie I have seen.


That’s totally valid. I think the film either resonates deeply or not at all, and both responses are completely legitimate. I can absolutely see how it could feel pretentious drivel to some. I assume for me it directly evokes emotions of my childhood (catholic upbringing by a loving mother). I also really appreciate you being happy for me. That's true empathy.



Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: