Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

What we need is the same thing we've needed for a long time now, ethical standards applied across the whole industry in the same way that many other professions are regulated. If civil engineers acted the way that software engineers routinely do, they'd never work again, and rightly so.



Are you suggesting working flexibly (maybe "agile"), is at odds with working ethically?


> If civil engineers acted the way that software engineers routinely do, they'd never work again, and rightly so.

This part is what I take issue with. Software is simply different from buildings.


Software still gets people killed, a lesson that should have been learned decades ago with the Therac-25. Of course "software is different from buildings," but the responsibility to build both ethically and responsibly isn't one of the differences. Granted the impacts of software are often less direct than a building collapse, but they still exist and the people involved in making it need to stop pretending that this is still the digital wild West.


The process of building a building ethically, and the process of building software ethically, are completely unrelated and different.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: