Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

I had a similar bad experience not with posting but with answering questions.

Some overly-zealous mod came and edited (!!!) what i wrote because they didn’t like the wording. No swear or any kind of trouble involved, they just didn’t like the words i used.

Picking the specific words, besides merely answering questions, is quite literally what makes me me and what makes someone else someone else, in a text-only community.

I never replied any other thread since then and never posted again. Whatever I write can be edited according to what random person somewhere thinks is better.

Going to extreme: if some mod decides to edit my comments to include racial slurs, that’s entirely within the realm of possibility.

I do not play that game.

No wonder they’re getting crushed by ChatGPT and other LLMs.






I often used to edit to format text (code formatting and text walls + typos).

I would never touch the wording though.


Yeah, i understand that you act in good faith, but having the possibility to be framed by some random mod putting words in my mouth is a risk not worth taking.

I don’t post or reply on stackoverflow.


There is a full history of changes.

Of course if you do not trust SO itself to not delete this history (mods cannot do it) then yes, that's a problem.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: