Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

> People getting together and doing things as a community does not require a government.

That may be true, but government (at least a democratic one) is just people getting together and doing things, so if you already have one you can save the effort of the community trying to organize a second community on top of the community they already have for no good reason.

> But labeling them as "people getting together and doing things as a community" ignores their ability to enforce their laws, including the sanctioned use of violence or the threat of violence to coerce people into obeying or to punish them.

That literally tells of people getting together and doing things. These are not magical powers. They are simply community action. I suppose it highlights that people getting together and doing things isn't all sunshine and rainbows, despite your apparent dream for a world where there is only happiness, but such is reality.

I expect the aversion is that those who wish to donate to charity only want their friends, not entire communities, to benefit. The "trouble" with a community at large is that everyone is able to participate, whether you like them or not. That's not to say that a community cannot see a charitable benefit indirectly, but the key point is that they want to keep the primary benefit away from strangers.




There are plenty of such organisations. Some are legal, some are not.

The government is the only one with a legal monopoly on violence; it redistributes resources in the society and it's not run by incorruptible angels but by fallible human beings - human beings who were put there thanks to investments of millions of dollars.

It's a recipe for disaster.


> It's a recipe for disaster.

Government is a recipe for disaster? Democratic government has worked for centuries without disaster.

> it's not run by incorruptible angels but by fallible human beings - human beings who were put there thanks to investments of millions of dollars.

Yes, that is the trick of every human endeavor, the great ones and the failures. It depends on you and me - let's make it happen.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: