Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

I disagree with the point about the word "fire". How can you criticize the English word used if historically they weren't even speaking English?

Scenes are depicted in English instead of the native language of the setting for the benefit of the audience (and budget), and in modern English it's perfectly okay to use "fire" as a translation for the act of loosing a bow, even if "loose" is more commonly used in archery.



But English-speaking places have bows and arrows. (Even a particularly famous historical one!). So it’s reasonable to expect a translation into English to use the English word for sending an arrow from a bow.

If it were some science fiction setting with a weapon very unlike any real historical weapons then sure, the particular etymology of the English word wouldn’t be very relevant.


There were no English-speaking places that used bows extensively. The closest would've been Early Modern English, which is still drastically different to Modern English.

If the actors were actually speaking Shakespearean English then sure, it would be wrong for them to say "fire"/"fyr", but if they did that then you wouldn't understand half of what they're saying.

I'm sure there's a few actual examples of this though, for scenes depicting battles in England after 1800 or so that use bows. I would still say it's debatable whether you could consider this truly modern English but it's close enough.


All of which is extraneous to the question, "Did armies use volleys of arrows?".

If the French-speaking English commanders at Agincourt told their archer captains to "Laissez-y" instead of "Fire!", what difference does that make?

(For context, King Henry V of Agincourt fame is considered to probably have been the first English monarch who spoke English as a mother tongue, and may have been the first who was remotely proficient in it.)


...Yeah? I'm not disagreeing with the rest of the article, just specifically the part about criticising media's use of the word "fire" instead of "loose".




Consider applying for YC's Fall 2025 batch! Applications are open till Aug 4

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: