Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Maybe. Or maybe you have no frame of reference for what it’s like to be born in, graduate high school in, or spend your whole life in a small town where one factory or one industry is the only thing keeping the entire place alive. Then you watch it disappear, not because people didn’t work hard enough or because the business wasn’t viable, but because it was cheaper to ship everything overseas to exploit workers who have no rights, or because some top-down regulation made it easier and more profitable to do just that somewhere else.

Of course maybe it’s not just losing a job. Maybe it’s watching your whole community fall apart piece by piece. Maybe the tax base dries up so the schools get worse, the local stores shut down, the houses rot, and the kids who can leave bounce the moment they’re able to. Maybe the ones who can’t are left behind with no real options and no way out leading to all the shitty outcomes one would expect. And maybe… none of the people responsible for any of it have to live with the fallout. The politicians, the executives, the media, none of them are losing sleep over it. Their towns don’t get gutted. Their futures don’t disappear. Their kids aren’t overdosing.

But hey, it’s probably easier to just write off 70 million people as brainwashed idiots who joined a cult for no reason. Occam’s razor certainly suggests that your internalized caricature courtesy of r/politics is far more likely than any of these far-fetched hypotheticals right?




>Then you watch it disappear, not because people didn’t work hard enough or because the business wasn’t viable, but because it was cheaper to ship everything overseas

That's fucking capitalism, the thing these voters dick suck all the time. They are constantly afraid of any government control of the economy or socialism in general


>Maybe it’s watching your whole community fall apart piece by piece. Maybe the tax base dries up so the schools get worse, the local stores shut down, the houses rot, and the kids who can leave bounce the moment they’re able to. Maybe the ones who can’t are left behind with no real options and no way out leading to all the shitty outcomes one would expect. And maybe… none of the people responsible for any of it have to live with the fallout. The politicians, the executives, the media, none of them are losing sleep over it. Their towns don’t get gutted. Their futures don’t disappear. Their kids aren’t overdosing.

No. No, it really isn't.

Because your sprawling victimhood narrative describes the situation of many in the US to some degree or another, but not even that of most Trump supporters. And not even most Trump supporters voted for him just for the catharsis of seeing the people they hate suffer. Although again, many did, and will admit so openly so I'm not the one engaging in caricature here. I never mentioned "brainwashed idiots" or a cult, although Trump does have an actual, literal goddamn cult so I don't even know what you're objecting to in that case.

It isn't my fault that the more you try to defend these people, the worse they come off.

Good day.


What exactly do you think the -ist part of “Trumpist” is referring to?

And no, it’s not everyone. It doesn’t need to be to win the election.

If it makes it easier to maintain your narrative of being on the good side, go ahead and pretend everyone who doesn’t agree with you is an asshole. Cheers.




Consider applying for YC's Fall 2025 batch! Applications are open till Aug 4

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: