Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Interesting. It is impressive that they almost managed to do 100% made in the USA, judging by the "Table of Origin". However the table doesn't really cover all the details down to the components, so I'm wondering where he sourced every small details.

He did include one paragraph on the website:

"Individual components used in fabrication are sourced direct from chip makers and parts distributors."



For reference, the table is on this page: https://puri.sm/products/liberty-phone/?ref=404media.co

Todd Weaver is vastly exaggerating how special, innovative, and skilled Librem is. Their components are largely sourced from overseas, through domestic distributors, which is the norm for electronics manufacturers; overseas distributors are often precluded from international sales by agreements with their suppliers. There are also far more skilled electronics designers in the USA than he seems to think.

Source: I am an embedded developer, who works on a research, design, and development team which includes electronics engineers, and works on products manufactured in the same facility.


> There are also far more skilled electronics designers in the USA than he seems to think.

Second this. The Liberty Phone PCBA isn't even that exotic as far as modern designs go. The NXP SoC (CPU) it uses is a common part with a rather pedestrian ball pitch. A board like this is within the reach of countless trained EEs here, but they're usually happily employed at companies with higher volumes and margins. This often translates to a perception that they don't exist in the US market when low-budget companies go looking.


I thought the phrasing of "western distributor" was shady. I'm like doesn't that just mean the person ordering and distrusting the parts is "in the west" (not even necessarily US) but the parts could be from anywhere? It's not saying much at all.


>"Individual components used in fabrication are sourced direct from chip makers and parts distributors."

I suspect most of those are from overseas. A lot of that stuff just isn't made in the US. I don't know why they are shady about it, they should just be honest and denote which stuff isn't available at all in the US and which stuff isn't available at reasonable costs in the US.


Are there any other ways to source components?




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: