Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

I don’t understand this take? They got to spend the better part of a year doing what they love. Sounds pretty kick-ass to me.



I doubt they're happy about having to be up there that long.


How long exactly do you think NASA astronauts typically spend on the ISS?


We’ll see if they fly again or they are done with space for good. There is no way they’ll publicly complain or acknowledge issues. as it will look unprofessional, but actions will tell.


Wasn't this (or rather, the original short mission) expected to likely be the last mission for them anyways, due to age?

I really hope they'll at some point clearly say either "well, of course we missed our families, but really, getting such an opportunity was AWESOME and Boeing's misfortune was a huge lucky event for us" or "Being up there is awesome, but quite honestly, having to do it unexpectedly really sucked".

And I don't think that it is the slightest bit unprofessional to have feelings about where you spent a year of your life, or to talk about those feelings.


> And I don't think that it is the slightest bit unprofessional to have feelings about where you spent a year of your life, or to talk about those feelings.

I think it’s cultural. Astronauts I think are more disciplined and more professional on average than an average Joe. Even if they hated it they probably wouldn’t mention it publicly. Maybe after they retire from NASA completely.


Conversely, I can't imagine them saying they were happy and lucky beyond their dreams, even if they felt that way, because "being in space is more awesome than having a life" would be a view too controversial to voice, and wouldn't be received well by most of society.


>Astronauts I think are more disciplined and more professional on average than an average Joe.

All astronauts are military service members. I'd expect nothing less.


Another member of Expedition 72 was 7 years Wilmore's senior.


This was likely their last mission to start with. They’re already past prime and nearing retirement (of official astronaut duties, at least).


I guess until they retire and leave NASA we may never know. Otherwise it would be quite unprofessional of them to criticize their time there or air out the dirty laundry.

The point is, they are expected to say they enjoyed every minute of it in front of the camera. And if they really didn’t we may not hear about it.





Consider applying for YC's Summer 2025 batch! Applications are open till May 13

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: