Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

I own an EV and while the instant torque is fun, nothing will ever come close to the joys of driving a manual sports car.



> nothing will ever come close to the joys of driving a manual sports car.

"joy" basically means: natural aspiration, low weight, manual gearbox, rear-wheel drive, hydraulic (or unassisted) steering and no traction control or ESP


I recently got an 81 Vanagon, it's got all of that except hydraulic steering and low weight, but I only have the two front seats which helps with weight a bit, and it's probably close to a light truck weight, back when they made light trucks. It's a lot of fun. No power steering, no power windows, no power from the engine, but I get to stomp on the throttle all the time.

Later model years added all sorts of bells and whistles like water cooling, power steering, and signs of life from the engine, but who needs that.



Ah, that joy. Had it crossing the Atlas mountain in Morocco, in a 35 HP FWD car. Low weight and simplicity, that's the key. Yeah, that won't return any time soon.

At the border crossing, we shared the queue with two of the five teams (according to Wikipedia) participating in the first ever 4L Trophy. When I'm gone (well, when we're gone, me and my peers at the time), those memories will be gone, it's how it is.


That’s right! There’s a reason nearly every city has a club of gutted Miatas.


As a six speed NB owner, am hard pressed to disagree.

I haven't driven another car yet that focused so well on the things that make driving fun, while minimizing the downsides.


Agreed. We bought my wife an NC last year when the criteria was “cheap, petrol, naturally aspirated and Japanese”. The criteria was in response to my Land Rover (Discovery / LR4) which is none of those things and becoming a bore.

After stealing the MX-5 whenever I get the chance I now wish we could run two. That would make family trips troublesome though…


> That would make family trips troublesome though

100%. As someone who drove said NB for a 6-hour trip twice a week for a period, it isn't the best grand tourer. ;)

It did make my heart sing to dust angry jacked up trucks with 3x+ the displacement / power, but who obviously didn't understand power:weight ratio.


I prefer NA but I can have a lot of joy with a proper turbo or two, or a supercharger. There’s a big difference between a turbo used to pass emissions standards and one installed for fun


> rear-wheel drive

meh, I was never a fan of those.

I still remember the day I took an audi quattro (not mine, a car like that was way out of my league financially back then) for the first time up a mountain pass road near my home in the 80s.

What an effing rush that was.

Strongly agree for the rest of the list though and would add: "mechanical handbrake" to the list.

These days cars have ugly little electronic handbrakes with a LED on it, what a load of shite.


while i agree the only thing i’ll note here is the aforementioned GTR (R35) never came in manual.

It’s definitely quite a bit lighter than the Tesla at least.


I totally agree. But why? The Evs have brutal acceleration and reach higher average speeds.

We should feel some excitement, yet I don’t even bother to have a spirited drive in an EV. The super fast ones just make you feel nauseous.


I love cycling way more, but then every random dog is trying to eat me. So ICE rules!




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: