Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

It's not rocket science

First, you're not blind - you can test your product to see what the "plenty" is.

Second, many components have rated use, so it's easy to estimate mean time to fail and pick the one beyond the warranty period with whatever buffer you like. It's not like you need seconds level of precision here!




Might I suggest reading about the normal distribution?

Or, I don’t know, perhaps giving slightly greater consideration to the people in this thread who’ve actually worked on physical device engineering?


The level of consideration matches the level of argumentation, e.g., it's obvious you failed in your interpretative nitpicking on the word "mean" and think "reading about the normal distribution" means anything in this context.


Appropriately for the topic, I tailored the level of consideration to just barely exceed that of your original argument. So, next to none.


Are you replying to yourself? You were the one demanding consideration, not me!


Please design a physical product to reliably fail after a specific and precise amount of time (not usage, because that’s easier and not what you’re arguing), then come back and describe how easily you accomplished that feat. Everyone reading this thread who has worked in device design knows that your assertions are completely and utterly misguided.


Right after you explain how in this imaginary world of 0 knowledge where you're not even capable of translating usage into time companies set a warranty to 3 years (>legal min) instead of 13; and why there are warranty limitations for heavy use.

(and no, you don't need "reliably ... specific and precise", those are just artifical constraints you've added)

And don't speak for everyone, not everyone is so clueless re. business decisions just because they've designed some hardware.


“I know so much more about this topic from some casual Googling than people who actually do this for a living, so please listen to me.”




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: