Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

I am not a piano player, or even an official player of any musical instrument. I don't know how to read music.

A year ago, we were offered an upright Kimball built in 1970 by my newly acquired in-laws. My father in law is a portly fellow and insisted we move it ourselves, but I instead paid exactly 300 dollars to have it moved the 14 miles from Exeter to Lee.

We let it adjust to the humidity in our house for a half a year, and then we paid exactly 175 dollars to have it tuned. As subjective as this is, the man who tuned it said "it was a D and now it is a B". He said that the Kimballs are a very cheap piano with a cheap sound, and tried to sell me a grand piano for 5000 dollars used. It would have required I vacate my home office to the basement.

He had other pianos for sale, and some were as affordable (but as cheap) as the 300 dollars I paid for a free piano.

It's immensely pleasurable having a piano next to where I program. I don't know what I am doing, but I suspect this is a lot of the allure - I sit there and poke, and figure out my programming challenge of the day while my fingers are occupied. We all know full well how the frontal lobe needs to be engaged for the "coprocessor" to have a chance at resolving our issues for us.

The piano is about 4 feet wide and barely 2 feet from the wall. Since the bench sits underneath, this is frankly not a huge investment in space. I recommend a piano highly to the non-player due to its affordability and its distraction properties, my own version of prayer beads I use while debugging in my head.




> It's immensely pleasurable having a piano next to where I program. I don't know what I am doing, but I suspect this is a lot of the allure - I sit there and poke, and figure out my programming challenge of the day while my fingers are occupied. We all know full well how the frontal lobe needs to be engaged for the "coprocessor" to have a chance at resolving our issues for us.

While not directly related, this is exactly the same reason I have a beater guitar hanging directly next to my workstation - if I get into a bit of tough code, I just take a break, strum a few chords, and then get back down to business.


This is terrific.

By the way, if you take just a handful of lessons, you'll probably get further with your playing than you might think. There's way too much "you have to learn music as a kid" mentality out there — adults can pick up the basics, too.

I estimate that anyone with a better-than-tin ear can play something like http://www.gmajormusictheory.org/Freebies/Classics/WTCPrelu.... in a matter of a few weeks after learning some scales.


You're talking about upright pianos... Affordability? Talking with other piano players, here in Spain you can't find a decent piano under 1000€. And, if you're going to buy a crappy piano for "getting distracted" that won't last more than 10 years, better search for a digital one: for the same price of a crappy piano you can get a pretty decent digital keyboard that will fit your needs (and will occupy even less space).


Fantastic! As a piano player myself I find that all too often we get tied up in theory or practice routines or grades. Sometimes you've just got to PLAY THE DAMNED THING.

Sort of applies to programming as well if you see what I mean.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: