Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

Do you think he should? Do you think it's a healthy exercise in the country's checks and balances for the president to create a precedent where he directs the justice department to not enforce a law when Congress has drafted it, and the Supreme Court has unanimously upheld it? Last time anything like this has happened, it created devastating national history.



I don't think the country fell apart when Obama directed the justice department not to enforce weed laws. [0]

[0] - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cole_Memorandum


I don't think this compares, but I do see where you're coming from. Whereas the present SC has unanimously upheld this TikTok law, The Court has avoided taking a position on federal non-enforcement of marijuana laws in states where it is legalized


Not enforcing laws by executive decision happens all the time. Whenever police "crack down" on something, that means they were previously letting stuff slide.


The law gives a new power. Doesn't say it has to be used. President can also nuke shit. Doesn't have to be used.


I'll take the bait. What was that last time and what was the devastating national history moment?


I mean the same exact criteria happened in Marbury v Madison and it changed the entire nation's check and balance system, lol. Many will claim for better, but the opportunity is definitely there for worse.


It wouldn’t be the first time an American President decided not to enforce a SC ruling.


I think actually it would be (if you are thinking of the Jackson one it’s not actually the way it’s popularly remembered)


How do you think Worcester v. Georgia happened in ways not popularly remembered?


Read the last few words in my GP, I know. Also, a law drafted by Congress AND an SC ruling upholding it??


How? The bill gives the president a power. SCOTUS has said the law is legal. Nothing compels the president to use the power. See Biden passing it along.




Consider applying for YC's Fall 2025 batch! Applications are open till Aug 4

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: