Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

[flagged]



> We don't have any studies showing that old people harm society using social media

an an american who just watched the recent election go down, I have to strongly disaagree with this.


That's obviously a biased statement. I happen to share your bias toward the election outcome, but I'm afraid analysis shows that GenZ has moved towards Republican in comparison with similar aged voters 4 and 8 years ago, while people over 60 have moved towards Dems. So your assumptions are not correct, apart from the fact that they're not even relevant to the discussion about the influence of social media (and mobile phones) on young people.


How can you justify that view? Harris lost because of voter turnout. I don't see how >60s are to blame for that. I also don't see how >60s are to be blamed for young people moving right.


> I also don't see how >60s are to be blamed for young people moving right.

Rebelling against the perceived establishment as presented to them by their teachers (some of whom are that old) probably had something to do with it. (Their parents too, but their parents aren't >60)

Young men particularly have been getting dosed with idpol messaging about men by their predominantly female teachers from a young age. Anecdotally, there's also a general thing where the older a teacher gets the more embittered by experience they become, and they become more likely to fall into negative behavior patterns like having "nemesis students" they like to pick on, or exhibiting flagrant bias in the classroom against an entire gender.


Yes, after years and years, we only recently have solid studies showing that social media harms individual children. I expect it’ll take a bit longer to finalize studies showing the harm to society.


And maybe once they exist it'll make sense to impose additional limitations on social media.

The overriding drive should be to make policy decisions based on strong evidence, not on sentiment. If that means we wait a bit longer then we wait a bit longer.


> Older adults are relatively more susceptible to impulsive social influence than young adults

https://www.nature.com/articles/s44271-024-00134-0

The number of test subjects is small, but hopefully this will lead to more funding for larger projects.


>Stupid, snarky comment intended to create division, that belongs in a trash heap like Reddit or Twitter, not here.

This also doesn’t belong here.


Hot take: most reddit discussions are every bit as good as HN comments. There is no need to make HN "not Reddit".




Consider applying for YC's Fall 2025 batch! Applications are open till Aug 4

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: