Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Couldn’t have said it any better myself


Except it makes no sense. Java is a language that, while idiomatically a bit boilerplatey, is generally a workhorse for getting shit done.


No I mean in Java it’s common to write extensive boilerplate and abstractions just bc it feels constructive. Java is extremely useful, but business use of it is not so nice


It’s everything but that. It’s the instrument of over engineering. Maybe not the language itself (it was the Rust if its time, everyone wanted to use it for everything, even if it made no sense), but the whole ecosystem just prefers complexity and breaking changes. Maybe it’s a coping mechanism for devs stuck with it, or I don’t know.


> it's the instrument of over engineering.

True, but find me one language that someone, somewhere didn't over- something. Either over-engineer or over-simplify, or over-use.

People get excited about technology and try to push the envelope on its usage. That's true of any widely used tech.

Hitting the golden middle is notoriously hard, especially when it is not the same middle for everyone.

> the whole ecosystem

What precisely do you mean? Sure Spring is notorious for this, but not the wider ecosystem.

Sure some libraries might not be using SemVer, but Maven itself predates it as well.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: