Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

I don't think this is an honest question.

There's no "fixed budget" of energy that is ethically ok to use. The parents point was that these devices are woefully inefficent no matter which way you look at them.

The "best" thing to do would be neither, and is usually to just use the device you have - particularly for low power electronics as the impact of buying a new one is more than the impact of actually running the thing unless you run it 24/7/365



> There's no "fixed budget" of energy that is ethically ok to use.

Not even 0.00001 W? How is it ethical to live in the first place in such case?

> The parents point was that these devices are woefully inefficent no matter which way you look at them.

It's always a trade off, of productivity, enjoyment vs energy efficiency, isn't it? If I find a setup that allows me to be more productive and enjoy my work more, certainly I would need to balance it with how much potential waste there is in terms of efficiency.

> The "best" thing to do would be neither, and is usually to just use the device you have

That's quite a generic statement. If my device is a budget android phone, do you expect me to keep coding on it, not buying better tools?


FWIW (just to clarify on this one area if I may)

>> There's no "fixed budget" of energy that is ethically ok to use.

> Not even 0.00001 W? How is it ethical to live in the first place in such case?

The idea of no fixed budget is there is no binary threshold. Where above is bad and below is okay. Just a spectrum.


> the impact of buying a new one is more than the impact of actually running the thing unless you run it 24/7/365

This is wrong for basically everything we ever use - from a house, to an electric car. And especially for small items like electronics


I’d be interested in hearing you reconcile your statement by making an ethical case for the energy use of video games and the hardware that runs them.

Is there a level of energy that is ethically okay to use for video games?


No more or less than any voluntary activity. What about baking for pleasure?

My point isn't that all energy use is bad, it's that there's no line that says "use to hear as you wish but everything after this is wrong"


Read up on the 2000 watts society




Consider applying for YC's Fall 2025 batch! Applications are open till Aug 4

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: