Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Rich kid's tuition and endowments from their families fund the school to a high level allowing them to pay for highly talented individuals and prestigious research. They might not do as well academically, but still get to trade on the name of having gone to the school

Smart kids get in on scholarships and grants and help uphold the prestige of the university name while getting access to the highly talented professors. They are able to take advantage of this access, do well in the school, and have prestigious results in the real world, move on to be involved in that prestigious research, etc.

You also have the elbow rubbing of the moneyed elite with people that might be very well suited to take that money and help grow it to even larger levels.

That's the idea, anyway. Whether or not it's reality, I don't know. I didn't attend an Ivy League (or quasi-Ivy League in Stanford's case) school. They also of course receive significant money from the government via grants as well, so it's not entirely all coming from the pockets of the rich.



> Rich kid's tuition and endowments from their families fund the school to a high level allowing them to pay for highly talented individuals and prestigious research

Are you predicting donations to Stanford and USC will crater to a level that existentially threatens either institution?


I'm predicting nothing. I replied to someone who asked for further clarification on how this theory is supposed to work.

I haven't put enough thought into it to have strong feelings one way or the other - I'm just aware of the argument being made.


God don't threaten me with a good time...


yep it pretty much works this way in practice. can confirm.


It's wild that the shorthand for "good school" is what sports division some schools in/around Massachusetts are in.


> It's wild that the shorthand for "good school" is what sports division some schools in/around Massachusetts are in.

Nice meme, but that really doesn’t do justice to the reality.

- Seven of the schools that became the Ivy League were “colonial colleges” (https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Colonial_colleges). William & Mary and Rutgers did not become part of the Ivy League, and Cornell (not a colonial college) did.

- They are all research universities, which makes them distinct from many colleges that seem to have similar origins.

- The schools are all in the northeast corridor, but Massachusetts is definitely on the Eastern side of the Ivy geographic area. Ivies center more around colonial era settlements than the state of Massachusetts.


Thanks for the explanation. Ivy League prestige disenchantment has reached a new high.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: