Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

[flagged]



We can play all the violins we want, we’re missing out on the future and that’s that.

“Drill baby drill” as trump says…vote this guy into oblivion.


It's relatively easy to get information about what goes on in China. You just have to speak/read Chinese. Then you have access to a social media environment with 1 billion+ people, and you can pretty easily learn about major happenings in the country.

If you don't know any Chinese, then you're reliant on Western media for your information about the country. The general level of coverage of China in Western media is abysmal. It's usually spotty, poorly informed and hyper-negative. Imagine if your only knowledge about the US were from news stories about school shootings. You'd have basically no idea about what the US is like.


One person's IP theft is another's free market. We could use weaker IP laws in the west.


And the IP does not belong to the American government, why are taxpayers forced to subsidize such an expensive and potentially dangerous endeavor anyway? Not to mention that IP theft hs two metaphors in it - property, and theft, as the equating of intellectual property - a statutory creation - and real property - which exists unless you don't believe in your lying eyes - is ultimately the bad faith muddling of legal fiction and reality. America would absolutely know the difference, as one of the most prolific thieves of real property in recent memory (see: why and how the state of Georgia exists in the first place, or 'manifest destiny', or 'civil asset forfeiture'). Since there is no private property in anything close to the way the west conceptualizes it in China, nor anything resembling rule of law, what even gives America the right, beyond realpolitik, to even assert not just equivocation but effective extraterritoriality considering that American courts have a presumption against extraterritoriality as part of its doctrines.

This is not to endorse the CCP in any of its actions, but it is really not the business of the American government to impose its definitions and legislations upon the world in such a cavalier fashion. The jingoistic stench is the free prize, and it creates an artificial unifying point for the CCP to rally its citizens, who all go through indoctrination in nationalism but certainly by no means all buy into it, to focus on something that, probably thanks to the lack of cultural and historical competence amongst government officials in general, reinforces the primary raison d'etre of the CCP in the first place. After all, it's effectively the last country to take Westphalian Sovereignty at face value, however insincere it might be. I would categorize American policy as neo-imperialist, but are Americans even bothered by the idea that they are the evil empire? Are we the baddies?


Arguably the US for where it is today by being too far away for European powers to enforce IP laws!




Consider applying for YC's Fall 2025 batch! Applications are open till Aug 4

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: