Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

People on the whole don't want a Jeremy Corbyn anyway - he led his party to the biggest labour defeat since 1935.

Don't know why the labour party would want to replicate that shit-show.




He was smeared with false antisemitism claims, hence the massive defeat. One of those involved in the smearing was... Starmer.

Corbyn was never going to be "allowed" to be Prime Minister. Also, listen to his recent interview where he says he was asked by a committee if he would guarantee to be 100% behind any military action instigated by Israel.


If anybody is interesting in learning more about that smearing campaing: https://www.ajiunit.com/investigation/the-labour-files

> An investigation based on the largest leak of documents in British political history. The Labour Files examines thousands of internal documents, emails and social media messages to reveal how senior officials in one of the two parties of government in the UK ran a coup by stealth against the elected leader of the party.


Politician smeared during election? Shock horror, it happens during every election.

Leader of the party can't unite their own party so there is a plan to oust them? That's politics.

Jeremy couldn't particularly unite the party, didn't take the center ground, and while I don't think he was a true antisemite there were enough mis-steps there that it meant that the claim could stick (along with the IRA sympathizer claims).


People on the whole want the policies, though.

That even Corbyn - the most vilified British politician of a generation - got that close to a win is a strong demonstration of that. Since then the Tory party support has collapsed to historic lows. A win on a program close in ambition to the 2017 manifesto - which was not in any way radical - should be a walk in the park for someone like Starmer in current conditions if he actually had dared try.


I think you're right - people are desperate for anything other than the Tories.

We have a political environment where the Greens are smeared as "crazies", people remember the Lib Dems for their deception, and mass media has many believing Reform will win if they don't vote for Labour. A Labour win is all but guaranteed, so Starmer doesn't need to be the other cheek of the Monoparty arse - he chooses to be.


But would the media have abandoned the Conservatives if Labour were offering something much different?




Consider applying for YC's Fall 2025 batch! Applications are open till Aug 4

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: