Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

I used it on Android and it seems to be one of very few apps that can replace the default Google services text-to-speech engine.

However, I wasn't satisfied with the speech quality so now I'm using RHVoice. RHVoice seems to produce more natural/human-sounding output yo me.



Depending on context, I cycle between espeak-ng with mbrola-en or RHVoice, but even plain espeak shouldn't be discarded.

RHVoice sounds slightly more natural in some cases, but one advantage of espeak-ng is that the text parsing logic is cleaner, by default.

For example, RHVoice likes to spell a lot regular text formatting. One example would be spelling " -- " as dash-dash instead of pausing between sentences. So while text sounds a little more natural, it's actually harder to understand in context unless the text is clean to begin with.

I don't know if speech-dispatcher does this for you, but I'm using a shell script and some regex rules to make the text cleaner for TTS which I don't need when using espeak-ng.

Another tradeoff: espeak-ng with the mbrola doesn't offer all the inflexion customization options you have with the "robotic-sounding" voices. When accelerating speech, these options make a qualitative difference in my experience.

I can see why each of these can have its place.


On android I use ETI-Eloquence, but you cant get a legal one. Google it and look on the website blind help. There is a apk.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: